American Spirit

From tried-and-true classics to new combinations, Bourbon-based cocktails are as popular as ever

Bourbon remains popular with U.S. consumers thanks to its authenticity and heritage. The First Class (pictured) from American Social Bar & Kitchen in Florida features Angel’s Envy Bourbon.
Bourbon remains popular with U.S. consumers thanks to its authenticity and heritage. The First Class (pictured) from American Social Bar & Kitchen in Florida features Angel’s Envy Bourbon.

Tequila may be today’s darling of the spirits industry, but good ol’ Bourbon isn’t going anywhere. “Not a shift goes by where someone doesn’t request a classic Old Fashioned or Manhattan, and often a Bourbon Sour of some sort,” says Aaron Tran, bartender at Cote Steakhouse in New York City and The Rockwell Place in Brooklyn, New York. “Many drinkers come to the bar with a basic understanding of major Bourbon labels and usually have their favorites and opinions about them. To me, the key to Bourbon’s popularity is its heritage here in the United States and how it’s a definitive icon of our drinking culture.”

Ross Boykin, general manager at Oribu in Washington D.C., also notes that guests seem to appreciate Bourbon’s “authenticity, heritage, and strong connection to American craftsmanship,” noting that it continues to be “one of the most requested spirits” at Oribu. “Guests today are more knowledgeable than ever, often asking about specific distilleries, barrel finishes, and limited releases,” he says, adding that Bourbon is also accessible. “It offers complexity for enthusiasts while remaining approachable for newer whiskey drinkers.”

Boykin notes that what he enjoys most about Bourbon, especially when it comes to crafting cocktails, is its depth and versatility. “It naturally contributes layers of vanilla, caramel, oak, spice, and texture, allowing bartenders to create cocktails that feel complex without requiring an excessive number of ingredients,” he says. “Bourbon is equally effective in elegant spirit-forward drinks, refreshing serves, and even dessert-inspired cocktails, which makes it an incredibly valuable tool behind the bar.”

Thanks to the Bourbon boom, bartenders and mixologists have their pick of unique Bourbon labels. At the Flatiron Room in New York City, Milam & Greene Triple Cask Bourbon is a favorite in the Orange Artichoke and Old Fashioned cocktails (pictured).
Thanks to the Bourbon boom, bartenders and mixologists have their pick of unique Bourbon labels. At the Flatiron Room in New York City, Milam & Greene Triple Cask Bourbon is a favorite in the Orange Artichoke and Old Fashioned cocktails (pictured).

Beloved Classics

Colby Poulin, beverage director for Nova Lounge at Vast restaurant in Oklahoma City, says that Bourbon “has been a go-to choice” for bartenders for quite some time. “Over the years, the Old Fashioned remains a dominating cocktail, with different compound syrups and aromatic bitters really creating an infinite number of choices for the consumer,” he adds.

The Old Fashioned has indeed been riffed on seemingly endlessly since its
invention in the 19th century, and especially within the last decade or two. At The Splendid in New York City, the Of Bread & Body ($22)—by beverage
manager Ian Pekar—is a banana bread-inspired take on the classic, featuring cinnamon-infused Elijah Craig Small Batch Bourbon, Tempus Fugit Crème De Banane banana liqueur, Giffard Crème de Cacao liqueur, saline solution, Bitter Queens Chocolate Walnut bitters, and Angostura bitters, garnished with a banana chip that’s been sprayed with Giffard Banane Du Brésil banana liqueur. At Hey Luigi in Portland, Oregon, meanwhile, the Old Bals ($15)—by chef, owner, and beverage director Gabriel Pascuzzi and bar manager Natane Adams— mixes Old Forester 100 Proof Bourbon, 25-year-old aged balsamic vinegar, Demerara syrup, Fee Brother Black Walnut bitters, and Angostura Bitters. And at Kampai in Jackson, Wyoming, the Open Sesame ($18)—by beverage director River Karlinski—blends sesame oil-washed Wyoming Whiskey Small Batch Bourbon, house-made cinnamon cordial, and Angostura bitters. “We wanted a whiskey cocktail that surprised people; it’s warm, a little savory, and unlike anything else on our menu,” Karlinski says.

At The Graceful Ordinary in St. Charles, Illinois, the Maple Old Fashioned ($14) comprises Widow Jane Aged 10 Years Bourbon, The Bitter Truth Pimento Dram liqueur, maple syrup, and Bitter Queens Sarsaparilla bitters. “I’ve noticed that the majority of guests have started to go back to basics with a flair—adjustments to syrups and bitters for Old Fashioneds is the main concept,” says bar director Lauren Porto. “Old Fashioneds are tried and true and will never go away, but I see more styles and recipes for new types showing up in restaurants.” Another twist on a classic, Porto’s Cubano Manhattan ($15) mixes Whiskey Acres Bottled in Bond Bourbon, Averna amaro, and Bitter Queens Caribbean Spice bitters and Tobacco bitters.

At Oribu, Boykin’s Applewood Smoked Old Fashioned ($18) is an applewood-smoked blend of Four Roses Small Batch Bourbon, Demerara syrup, Angostura bitters, and Regans’ No. 6 bitters, while his Sakura Boulevardier ($20) features Four Roses, Campari aperitif, Carpano Antica Formula sweet vermouth, house-made cherry blossom tea syrup, and Angostura Orange bitters. “For cocktails, I generally gravitate toward a higher corn Bourbon because the added sweetness helps the whiskey maintain its presence when mixed with other ingredients—brands like Four Roses Small Batch, Woodford Reserve, and Angel’s Envy are excellent examples because they offer balance, structure, and consistency while remaining cocktail-friendly,” Boykin says. “When selecting a Bourbon for a specific cocktail, however, the choice ultimately depends on the flavor profile we’re trying to achieve. Different Bourbons can create dramatically different results even when using the same recipe.”

Luis Zammaretto, head bartender at The Flatiron Room in New York City, favors Milam & Greene Triple Cask Bourbon. “Built from a blend of three distinct whiskies—two featuring malted rye as the secondary grain, alongside a third undisclosed mash bill—the Triple Cask is a standout in versatility,” he notes. “It delivers whether poured neat to explore its complexity, over a large rock for slow sipping, or stirred into a cocktail. While it shines in a classic or fat-washed Old Fashioned, it truly excels as the anchor in the Orange Artichoke, a rich Manhattan variation.” The drink ($23), which Zammaretto created, comprises Milam & Greene Triple Cask Bourbon, Nonino and Cynar amari, Winestillery red vermouth, and Regans’ No. 6 Orange bitters.

“The great thing about Bourbon is that there’s a brand and style for everyone; some can be incredibly light in flavor and aroma, others can be quite bold and full-bodied depending on their pedigree,” says Nic Wallace, resort bars and spirits manager at Sea Island, a private island resort off the southeast coast of Georgia. “While there’s no universal standard for what to pair with all of them, my usual guidelines are this: Taste the Bourbon first and determine the base flavor notes, then accentuate from there. Lighter styles work beautifully in Highballs and sparkling cocktails such as a Mule. Bolder Bourbons tend to have deeper and richer flavors of spices and cooked fruits or chocolate, making them the perfect carriers for vermouth, amaro, and bittersweet ingredients.” Served for Sea Island’s annual Derby Party, Wallace’s The Forbidden Julep ($22) mixes Forbidden Small Batch Select Bourbon, Blended Family Peach liqueur, house-made orange honey oleo saccharum, Angostura bitters, and muddled fresh mint for a fruit-forward take on the classic Mint Julep.

While spirit-forward classics are excellent vehicles for Bourbon, bartenders are pushing the boundaries with Bourbon lately and featuring it in all types of cocktail builds. At Hey Luigi, Pascuzzi and Adams’ Ernesto’s Garden Stroll ($17) is an Espresso Martini riff with added brightness from citrus, comprising equal parts espresso-infused Basil Hayden Bourbon and Grind Espresso Shot liqueur, plus Galliano L’Autentico liqueur and house-made lemon super foam. “Bourbon-based cocktails have become much more nuanced rather than simply spirit-forward,” Pascuzzi notes. “We will likely continue to see lighter, more playful Bourbon cocktails in the future.”

 

Bartenders are getting creative with classic Bourbon drinks. At Jackson, Wyoming’s Kampai, the Open Sesame (pictured) features sesame oil-washed Wyoming Whiskey Small Batch Bourbon, house-made cinnamon cordial, and Angostura bitters.
Bartenders are getting creative with classic Bourbon drinks. At Jackson, Wyoming’s Kampai, the Open Sesame (pictured) features sesame oil-washed Wyoming Whiskey Small Batch Bourbon, house-made cinnamon cordial, and Angostura bitters.

Refreshing Perspective

Tran of Cote Steakhouse and The Rockwell Place agrees that Bourbon-based cocktails are becoming more experimental. More specifically, they’re “often leaning toward a more refreshing profile in contrast to the usual way Bourbon has been typically enjoyed—as a spiritous and brooding tipple to sip,” he says. “Bourbon shouldn’t be—and no longer is—limited to stirred and boozy style beverages, and the enjoyers and creators of cocktails are embracing Bourbon’s refreshing era.”

Paul Rogers, lead bartender at Marsh House at the Thompson Hotel in Nashville, Tennessee, goes so far as to say whiskey cocktails “need a break from the confines of the Old Fashioned”—though he concedes that it’s a delicious cocktail when done right. “But if I choose to drink a cocktail with a whiskey base I want something that pays tribute to the mwspirit’s warmth and richness while introducing a balance of bright freshness—something crushable,” he explains. “I love a shaken whiskey cocktail that has the appropriate balance of citrus and bitter. Sherry wine has such a diverse spectrum of savory and sweet with a built-in backbone of acid that can do wonders in a whiskey cocktail. A whiskey drink incorporating some type of Sherry always catches my eye.” His Good Samaritan ($14) features equal parts Whiskey Jypsi Explorer Bourbon, Lustau Amontillado Sherry, Giffard Banane du Brésil, and lemon juice, while his Bill Brasky ($14) blends Whiskey Jypsi Explorer, Laird’s Bonded apple brandy, Strega liqueur, honey syrup, and Angostura bitters.

“Bourbon gives us the opportunity to balance familiarity with exploration; our Smoked Old Fashioned has been our bestselling cocktail for the past eight years, so we know our guests respond to drinks that are recognizable and spirit-forward, but they also want a reason to try something new,” says Dominic Sala, regional beverage director for American Social Bar & Kitchen, which has locations throughout Florida. “The First Class uses our hand-selected Angel’s Envy Bourbon and Italicus to create a brighter, slightly sweeter expression while not hiding the Aperol. The bergamot complements the lemon and keeps the drink balanced between sweet, tart, and bitter.” The drink ($17-$18, depending on location) mixes equal parts private selection Angel’s Envy Bourbon, Aperol aperitif, Italicus Rosolio di Bergamotto bergamot liqueur, and lemon juice.

Similarly a riff on the Paper Plane, the Aereo Elefante ($16) at Frannie & The Fox in the Emeline hotel in Charleston, South Carolina comprises equal parts Beyond Distilling Bourbon, See the Elephant amaro, Giffard Crème de Pamplemousse Rose pink grapefruit liqueur, and lemon juice, plus fresh basil. “I personally love to use light flavors to still ensure the Bourbon is the front runner in the cocktail,” says Amanda PEKARPhelps, who created the cocktail and serves as area director of beverage for the Emeline as well as The Ryder Hotel. “Coconut or banana are my favorites.” Her Mister Dexter ($16) features Virgil Kaine Rip Track Bourbon, Giffard Banane du Brésil, Demerara syrup, and lemon and grapefruit juices. Her Full Monte ($16), meanwhile, blends equal parts Beyond Distilling Bourbon and Cocchi Americano aperitif, plus Montenegro amaro and house-made apple shrub.

“While classics like the Old Fashioned and Manhattan remain popular, guests are increasingly looking for more approachable, creative, and seasonally driven expressions of Bourbon,” Oribu’s Boykin notes. “We’ve seen bartenders move beyond strictly spirit-forward recipes and incorporate fresh fruit, honey, herbs, Asian-inspired ingredients, and lower-ABV modifiers to create more dynamic cocktails.” Boykin’s Smoked Peach Bourbon Highball ($16) is a mesquite wood-smoked mix of Woodford Reserve Bourbon, Giffard Pêche de Vigne peach liqueur, fresh lemon juice, and club soda, while his Kyoto Gold ($20) comprises Angel’s Envy Bourbon, honey syrup, lemon and yuzu juices, and Angostura bitters.

Nova Lounge’s Poulin also notes “delving into refreshing-style Bourbon cocktails” behind the bar. “In particular, we’ve been serving fruited Cobblers—it’s a beautiful drink, served over crushed ice, topped with fresh fruit, and still has a strong backbone of Bourbon, and here at Nova, we split-base it with Cognac,” he says. “It’s very much an adult snow cone and really quenches the thirst.” His Bourbon and Brandy Cobbler ($14) features equal parts pineapple and peach-infused Blue Note Juke Joint Bourbon and Pierre Ferrand Cognac plus acid-adjusted pineapple juice, honey syrup, Angostura bitters, and muddled fresh peach and mint.

The Graceful Ordinary’s Porto says that “Whiskey Sours are huge crowd-pleasers and New York Sours are making a comeback—both are on the upswing.” At The Graceful Ordinary, bartender Miles Harris’s Lemon Balm Whiskey Sour ($16) blends a single barrel pick of Heaven Hill Bottled-In-Bond Bourbon, lemon juice, house-made lemon balm syrup, and egg white. At Evelyn’s at the Hutton Hotel in Nashville, Tennessee, the In Its Right Place ($15) takes inspiration from the New York Sour, featuring a base of house-made milk punch comprising Bib & Tucker Double Char Bourbon, Toutain Calvados, and Cappellano Barolo Chinato vermouth, which is then topped with Felino Malbec and a house-made passion fruit foam. “Typically when we think about a Bourbon cocktail, the first thing that comes to mind is probably stirred and brown—In Its Right Place was born from intentionally stepping outside of that box to make something that would appeal to a broader audience, highlighting some of the key flavors of Bourbon in an atypical way,” says bartender Dan King, who created the drink and serves as director of outlets at the Hutton. “The flavor profile focuses on the oak influence at first—vanilla, baking spices, roasted nuts, dry wood—but balances it out with citrus and tropical passion fruit, and black cherry and plum from the Malbec. It sort of sends a shock to the system that makes your brain question whether it’s a Bourbon cocktail at all, but the beauty is that you get to see an old familiar friend from a new perspective and come to appreciate flavors of the Bourbon that you may have never truly tasted this way before.”

Bourbon-Based Cocktails

Cubano Manhattan

Lauren Porto
Ingredients

2 ounces Whiskey Acres Bottled
in Bond Bourbon;
3/4 ounce Averna amaro;
3 dashes Bitter Queens Caribbean
Spice bitters;
3 dashes Bitter Queens
Tobacco bitters;
Luxardo cherry.

Recipe

In an ice-filled mixing glass, combine Bourbon, amaro, and bitters. Stir and strain into a coupe glass and garnish with a Luxardo cherry.

Aereo Elefante

Amanda Phelps
Ingredients

3/4 ounce Beyond Distilling Bourbon;
3/4 ounce See the Elephant amaro;
3/4 ounce Giffard Crème de
Pamplemousse Rose pink
grapefruit liqueur;
3/4 ounce lemon juice;
6 basil leaves.

Recipe

In an ice-filled cocktail shaker, combine Bourbon, amaro, liqueur, juice, and 5 basil leaves, each torn. Shake and strain into a Nick and Nora glass and garnish with remaining basil leaf.

Kyoto Gold

Ross Boykin
Ingredients

2 ounces Angel’s Envy Bourbon;
3/4 ounce honey syrup;
3/4 ounce fresh lemon juice;
1/4 ounce yuzu juice;
2 dashes Angostura bitters;
Lemon peel.

Recipe

In an ice-filled cocktail shaker, combine Bourbon, juices, syrup and bitters. Shake and strain into an ice-filled double rocks glass. Garnish with an expressed lemon peel.